I mean, really. I’m of the belief that something neither hot nor cold is worse than something too hot or too cold. “Stuck in the middle” is the last place in the world I’d want to find myself.
That said, I recently caved to my own internal pressures and bought two LPs, digitally, from iTunes. They’re both the latest work from artists I know, and know I like, for the most part: Cat Power and Belle & Sebastian (both, incidentally, on Matador).
First, let me just say I don’t read reviews. I know, odd thing to put forth in the process of writing one. I just don’t like going into things with specific expectations. Reviews for me are more a forum to discuss a work after the fact.
Second, on the subject of mediocrity, there are many ways overall impressions can be sliced. You can take the work in question, diced up (the forest for the trees approach). Or you can look at the work in relation to the artist’s entire oeuvre.
In both senses, these two records are…tepid, at best.
Another thing to consider is the variety of “chapters” within the “novels” of The Greatest and The Life Pursuit.
I was turned onto Cat Power’s newest after seeing the video for “Living Proof,” directed by Harmony Korine. It’s really a beautiful, whacky video, and the song stuck with me. All the more reason to buy the album, or so I thought.
Turns out that’s the only really memorable track, at least so far. The album was being hailed as some kind of sea change departure from past melancholy efforts. I disagree, completely. Plenty of maudlin pianos accompany Chan Marshall’s swooning depresso vocals. I like that stuff, don’t get me wrong. But in this effort, it all more or less blends together, and nothing sticks, save some of Karine’s visual imagery. “The Moon” is the only possible exception, and I’m giving it a few chances.
On The Life Pursuit, on the other hand, I was immediately taken by how much Belle & Sebastian seemed to have “got it back” (meaning I was less than impressed by the band’s last full-length, Storytelling, the soundtrack for the movie of the same name).
Right from the start, the band is back, all members, playing all instruments like the Belle & Sebastian of my college days. Stuart Murdoch is again witty and weaving and rolling in his vocal melodies. The best thing to do with your pain, as any fan of Morrissey knows all too well, is to make fun of it, in song if possible. That’s a big part of the allure of B&S, and the first few tracks of this album hit that mark, reeking of the days of If You’re Feeling Sinister and Boy With the Arab Strap.
But then I started to notice something odd: almost every track has backing vocals, ’70s style. There’s no blanket rule that backing vocals are a no-no, but it starts to feel trite here. “White Color Boy” (third track) is the first example, and after that, there are just too many others to go into depth about.
On the very un-B&S “The Blues Are Still Blue,” Murdoch really sounds like he’s trying to be “cool,” which, ahem, he’s not. That’s why I’ve loved this band in the past.
“Dress Up In You,” on the other hand, is beautiful. It’s more like the old, simple tunes of old.
The White Boy-Funky “Song For Sunshine” simply had to have been written for commercial purposes. I refuse to believe otherwise.
The overall point here is: The Life Pursuit is a mixed bag. It meanders between being really good, really on, catchy, and just missing the mark, trying too hard. Too bad.